Monday to Friday: 9 AM - 5 PM
Gabon St., Kirkos Sub-City, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Email Us at
contact@domain.com
Call Us at
0915735560
Get Started
Learn More
blog
Home » Uncategorized  »  Cassation Cassation Case No.: 211694
Cassation Cassation Case No.: 211694

Date: February 28, 2014 E.C.

Legal Rule (Interpretation of Law):

  1. Conditions for Granting Injunctions: Injunctions to prevent the sale of property can be granted by courts before a final judgment is reached in a case. Such injunctions are issued under specific provisions of the Civil Procedure Code (specifically Articles 154 and 155 in this case). The key conditions for granting an injunction are:
  1. Risk of Harm: The action sought to be prevented (in this case, the sale of the property) must be likely to cause harm to the other party in the case.
  2. Connection to the Dispute: The property subject to the injunction must be related to the subject matter of the ongoing lawsuit.
  3. Irreparable Harm: The harm that would result from the sale of the property must be such that it cannot be adequately compensated for later (irreparable harm).
  4. Bank's Right to Sell Mortgaged Property: While banks have the right under proclamation 97/90 to sell mortgaged property to recover debts, this right is not absolute. A court can issue an injunction to prevent the sale if the mortgagor has filed a lawsuit challenging the underlying obligation or the mortgage itself, and if the sale would jeopardize the mortgagor's rights or render the lawsuit meaningless.
  5. Relationship between Principal Obligation and Security: A security interest (like a mortgage) is an accessory obligation, meaning it is dependent on the validity of the principal obligation (the debt). If the principal obligation is extinguished or invalidated, the security interest is also extinguished. Therefore, if a lawsuit challenges the validity of the debt that underlies a mortgage, it is appropriate for a court to issue an injunction preventing the sale of the mortgaged property until the lawsuit is resolved.
  6. Impact of Injunction on Bank's Rights: An injunction preventing the sale of mortgaged property does not permanently deprive the bank of its rights. It merely suspends the exercise of those rights until the underlying legal dispute is resolved. If the court ultimately rules in favor of the bank, the bank can then proceed with the sale. The purpose of the injunction is to preserve the status quo and ensure that the court's eventual judgment is not rendered meaningless.
  7. Applicability of Proclamation 97/90: Proclamation 97/90 grants banks the power to sell mortgaged property outside of court proceedings. However, this proclamation does not preclude courts from issuing injunctions in appropriate circumstances to prevent such sales, particularly when the underlying debt or the mortgage agreement itself is the subject of ongoing litigation. The bank's rights under the proclamation are not absolute and can be limited by court order to protect the rights of the mortgagor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *